With gas prices fluctuating and environmental concerns growing, fuel efficiency matters more than ever. But buying a fuel-efficient car should also make financial sense—the fuel savings need to offset any price premium. We've analyzed the best fuel-efficient vehicles and calculated both their out-the-door costs and 5-year fuel savings to help you make a smart choice.
Calculate your exact out-the-door price
The redesigned Prius delivers 57 MPG combined with a much more stylish design than previous generations. It's the benchmark for hybrid efficiency and Toyota reliability.
MSRP range: $28,545 - $35,560. Estimated out-the-door range: $31,500 - $39,500.
At 54 MPG combined, the Elantra Hybrid matches the Prius in efficiency while offering a sportier design and Hyundai's excellent warranty coverage.
MSRP range: $28,550 - $32,200. Estimated out-the-door range: $31,500 - $36,000.
For those wanting a midsize sedan, the Accord Hybrid delivers 48 MPG combined without sacrificing interior space or comfort. It drives like a regular Accord with hybrid fuel savings.
MSRP range: $32,990 - $38,985. Estimated out-the-door range: $36,500 - $43,500.
The Camry Hybrid achieves 52 MPG combined and offers Toyota's legendary reliability. For buyers prioritizing dependability alongside efficiency, it's hard to beat.
MSRP range: $30,495 - $35,640. Estimated out-the-door range: $33,500 - $39,500.
The most affordable way to get 50+ MPG. The Corolla Hybrid delivers 53 MPG combined at a price point that makes the hybrid premium pay off quickly.
MSRP range: $24,495 - $26,600. Estimated out-the-door range: $27,000 - $29,500.
Calculate your actual fuel savings. At $3.50/gallon and 12,000 miles/year, going from 30 MPG to 50 MPG saves about $560 annually.
Consider how long you'll keep the car. Hybrid premiums ($2,000-$4,000) typically pay off after 4-7 years of driving.
Don't forget about insurance. Hybrid vehicles sometimes cost slightly more to insure due to repair costs.
Check for federal and state incentives. While most hybrids don't qualify, some plug-in hybrids offer $2,500-$7,500 in tax credits.
Compare total cost of ownership, not just MPG. A more expensive hybrid that holds its value may cost less over 5 years.
If you drive 12,000+ miles annually and keep the car 5+ years, hybrids typically pay off. The break-even point is usually 4-7 years depending on gas prices.
The Toyota Prius leads at 57 MPG combined. If you include plug-in hybrids driven mostly on electricity, the Toyota Prius Prime can achieve 100+ MPGe.
No—hybrid maintenance costs are similar to regular vehicles. Hybrid batteries typically last 150,000+ miles, and regenerative braking means brake pads last longer.
Hybrids are better if you can't charge at home or regularly drive long distances. EVs offer lower fuel costs if you can charge overnight and don't need 300+ miles of range daily.